Series: National Geographic Kids
Hardcover: 272 pages
Publisher: National Geographic Children's Books; 53565th edition (October 12, 2010)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1426301642
ISBN-13: 978-1426301643
Product Dimensions: 9.1 x 0.9 x 11.1 inches
Shipping Weight: 3.2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 4.8 out of 5 stars See all reviews (256 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #5,624 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #1 in Books > Children's Books > Education & Reference > History > Prehistoric #6 in Books > Children's Books > Education & Reference > Reference > Encyclopedias #6 in Books > Reference > Encyclopedias & Subject Guides > Children's
Age Range: 7 - 10 years
Grade Level: 2 - 5
I bought this National Geographic Kids Ultimate Dinopedia based on all of the positive reviews for my 3.5 year old dinosaur obsessed son. My son loves to look at the profiles of dinosaurs and memorize their names, and characteristics (i.e., what they eat, where they lived, etc). So, I perused for a dinosaur encyclopedia to help my son memorize different dinosaurs, which he loves to do.Before purchasing this book, I checked out some of the sample pages of this Dinopedia and I was impressed by the information provided on the pages and the artwork. The few pages I checked out had full profiles of the dinosaurs that they discussed. However, when we started reading the book my son became very frustrated because many of the dinosaurs profiled only have artistic pictures of their heads or parts of their bodies. (See, for example, Tsintaosaurus page 175, Plateosaurus page 181, Muttaburrasaurus page 163, Heterodontosaurus page 157 and the list goes on and on). For us, this makes this book largely ineffective for helping my son identify dinosaur names by sight. This is because many dinosaurs look similar and it is only by seeing a full body profile of each dinosaur that my son can distinguish between many dinosaurs that have similar bodies or features. I should mention though, that on the opposing page of the in-color artistic image of each dino in this Dinopedia there is a small, thumb size, all black, side profile of each dino. However, I don't think a tiny, all blacked out profile of the dinosaurs in this book really helps much with dinosaur identification.We also own a different and much smaller book of dinosaurs that illustrates the full bodies of the dinosaurs and my son has almost all of the dinos in that book memorized based on the pictures in the book.
Short version: If you want the best encyclopedic dino book for casual readers, get Holtz's "Dinosaurs".* Despite its title, Lessem's "The Ultimate Dinopedia: The Most Complete Dinosaur Reference Ever" (I.e. Dinopedia) is a mixed bag at best & a complete failure at worst.Long version: Read on.You could say Don Lessem is the Don Bluth of dinos: Bluth's pre-1990 work is mostly good, while his post-1990 work is mostly not-so-good; The same goes for Lessem's pre- & post-2000 work, respectively. In my previous review, I referred to "Dinosaur Worlds" as 1 of Lessem's best/most underrated books. This review is about Dinopedia, 1 of Lessem's worst/most overrated books: Overrated because it's more popular than it should be; Worst because of the reasons listed below.1) Dinopedia is a mixed bag in terms of paleoart. In fact, it reminds me of Long's "Feathered Dinosaurs" (Quoting Miller: "I bought the book expecting a more technical discussion of the animals discussed therein...but was surprised to find beautiful paintings of questionably-restored dinosaurs"), but less beautiful & more questionable. For instance, the dromaeosaurs (I.e. My favorite dinos) range from being completely feathered (Microraptor) to lacking primaries (Buitreraptor) to lacking wing feathers altogether (Velociraptor & Deinonychus) to being completely naked (Utahraptor). I could list the other things wrong with Dinopedia's paleoart, but this review is running long. Instead, I'll refer you to Vincent's "Ten Commandments for Dinosaur Collectibles" (Google "Ten Commandments for Dinosaur Collectibles", which sums up everything wrong with said paleoart).2) Dinopedia is a confusing mess in terms of organization: The 1st section (I.e.
National Geographic Kids Ultimate Dinopedia: The Most Complete Dinosaur Reference Ever Ultimate Bugopedia: The Most Complete Bug Reference Ever (National Geographic Kids) National Geographic Guide to National Parks of the United States, 8th Edition (National Geographic Guide to the National Parks of the United States) National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of Why (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of Dinosaurs (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of Birds (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of Bugs (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of Animals (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of the Ocean (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of How (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) National Geographic Kids First Big Book of Space (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) National Geographic Kids Almanac 2014 (National Geographic Kids Almanac (Quality)) National Geographic Kids Almanac 2013 (National Geographic Kids Almanac (Quality)) National Geographic Kids Almanac 2012 (National Geographic Kids Almanac (Quality)) National Geographic Kids Almanac 2011 (National Geographic Kids Almanac (Quality)) National Geographic Kids Almanac 2010 (National Geographic Kids Almanac (Quality)) National Geographic Little Kids First Big Book of the World (National Geographic Little Kids First Big Books) Dinosaur Adult Coloring Book: Dinosaur Coloring Book, a Adult Coloring Book containing Dinosaur images filled with beautiful and stress relieving patterns National Geographic Wild Animal Atlas: Earth's Astonishing Animals and Where They Live (National Geographic Kids) Ultimate Reptileopedia: The Most Complete Reptile Reference Ever