Paperback: 144 pages
Publisher: First Second; Original edition (February 15, 2011)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 1596434503
ISBN-13: 978-1596434509
Product Dimensions: 8.5 x 0.5 x 10.8 inches
Shipping Weight: 14.4 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review: 3.7 out of 5 stars See all reviews (10 customer reviews)
Best Sellers Rank: #283,045 in Books (See Top 100 in Books) #19 in Books > Teens > Historical Fiction > Exploration & Discovery #32 in Books > Children's Books > Comics & Graphic Novels > History #168 in Books > Comics & Graphic Novels > Graphic Novels > Historical & Biographical Fiction
Age Range: 12 - 18 years
Grade Level: 7 and up
As excited as I was about getting my hands on Nick Bertozzi's LEWIS & CLARK, I have to say that it turned out to be a sad disappointment to read. Full of inacccurate historical details and incorrect details in Bertozzi's illustrations; the book fell far short of my expectations. Bertozzi's uniforms are pretty sad. His Indians are cookie-cutter stereotypes, both in appearance and in their speech. Lewis comes off as a raging lunatic (hardly the sort of man that Thomas Jefferson would have had as a Private Secretary...or sent to lead an expedition!). Having participated in the recent L&C Bicentennial observance, I just found myself wondering where Bertozzi got his information and his ideas? It seems to me that Nick Bertozzi took a fantastic tale of true adventure and tried to 'improve' on what is already a great story. Sometimes you just cannot make a great story better by exercising 'artistic license'. Looking at the bibliography on the last page of the book, I found myself wondering if the author READ any of the volumes he cites???Nice 'comic book'. Disappointing historical graphic novel.
This is a waste of time. I liked Bertozzi's Shackleton, and I'm used to his style of modernizing history, but really. This is a humdrum treatment of the Lewis & Clark expedition, downplaying the courage and achievements. Some of the lighter parts of the book were too jokey, esp the mistranslations. The book focuses too particularly on Lewis's mental state.Good points:The wildlife is drawn wellThe Mandan village and the Fort were depicted very well.We did the L&C trail several years ago as a family. If you need a graphic book on the expedition, try Rosemary Schanzer's. For a personal favorite, try Lewis and Clark and Me by LauRie Myers.Other L&C materials at this Listmania.https://www..com/Lewis-and-Clark-Summer-Vacation/lm/R1Y42NR2JZBEVM/cm_lm_byauthor_title_full
It's fairly shameful that I went to a college named after these guys, and I know very little about their expedition. So when I came across this in a search for stuff for my 3rd-grader to read, I figured the least I could do was spend the hour to read it myself. It's kind of an impressionistic take on what really comes across as an astonishing trailblazing venture. The artwork and approach is quite good at conveying the sense of some of the hardships involved. There's a lot going on, with minor threads involving Clark's slave, Sacajawea, Lewis' depression, and more. It's kind of a lot to take in, along with tonal shifts (including fart gags) that are occasionally jarring. Probably the most interesting aspect, which is kind of confusingly rendered here, is all the interactions with various tribes they encountered along the way. It kind of sparked my appetite to learn a little more, and maybe pick up one of the standard histories, such as Stephen Ambrose's Undaunted Courage: Meriwether Lewis, Thomas Jefferson, and the Opening of the American West. And although I lament the absence of a more detailed map of the route, the book's overall design and repeated commitment to inventive double-page spread layouts made it a little more interesting than the standard graphic book.
When I read this I thought, "Well, that's the good, the bad and the ugly of the Lewis and Clark story." Fun to read, but definitely comic book fiction, this will probably appeal most to middle school boys, after all it's a story about a bunch of men basically living together for a long period. I was disappointed that Sacagewea's prowess was not applauded. Most of the story is about Meriwether Lewis, who deteriorates into a not-so- likeable guy. Mild-mannered Bill Clark seems to get lost in the shuffle. Dare I say that although Native American tribes are named and differentiated, they blend into the same stereotype. However, dates, territorial maps, and historical informative bits are helpful to those who have forgotten or were never taught about this expedition: Jefferson is president, the USA ends at the Mississippi River, the date of the expedition is 1803/4 to 1806.
The Essential Lewis and Clark (Lewis & Clark Expedition) The Journals of Lewis and Clark (Lewis & Clark Expedition) The Suppressed History of America: The Murder of Meriwether Lewis and the Mysterious Discoveries of the Lewis and Clark Expedition Nighttime Is My Time by Clark, Mary Higgins, Clark (2009) Audio CD What Was the Lewis and Clark Expedition? Lewis & Clark The Lewis and Clark Expedition Coloring Book (Dover History Coloring Book) Lewis and Clark: A Prairie Dog for the President (Step into Reading, Step 3) The Lewis and Clark Expedition (True Books: Westward Expansion (Paperback)) How We Crossed The West: The Adventures Of Lewis And Clark You Wouldn't Want to Explore With Lewis and Clark!: An Epic Journey You'd Rather Not Make Lewis and Clark for Kids: Their Journey of Discovery with 21 Activities (For Kids series) New Found Land: Lewis and Clark's Voyage of Discovery A Picture Book of Lewis and Clark (Picture Book Biography) Lewis and Clark and Me: A Dog's Tale Blazing West, the Journal of Augustus Pelletier, the Lewis and Clark Expedition, 1804 (My Name Is America) The Journal of Augustus Pelletier: The Lewis and Clark Expedition, 1804 (My Name is America) Dog of Discovery: A Newfoundland's Adventures with Lewis and Clark Bold Journey: West with Lewis and Clark The Captain's Dog: My Journey with the Lewis and Clark Tribe